Turning Conflict Into Connection

A Leadership Guide to Better Disagreements

Mindful Politics, Part 2 of a 4-Part Series

Conflict isn’t a sign of poor leadership—it’s a gateway to clarity, connection, and progress. When handled with intention, it can realign strategies, strengthen teams, and spark innovation. Psychologist and author Adam Grant reminds us, “We should agree to disagree more often. Avoiding minor arguments is a missed opportunity for learning.” In this second edition of our mindful politics series, we’ll look at how leaders can embrace disagreement as a powerful practice. Let’s turn friction into fuel for growth.

---

Common Leadership Pitfalls in Disagreements

One common leadership pitfall in disagreements is the need to be right, where leaders focus on proving their point rather than fostering collaboration, ultimately stifling innovation and trust. Another is attachment to the outcome, which can cause leaders to push for a specific resolution rather than staying open to new perspectives and potential solutions. I’m quite sure I’m guilty of both!

Here are a few more examples of common pitfalls:

• Communication Framing Matters – Saying, “We need to streamline our hiring process because I care about efficiency,” may unintentionally suggest that others do not. Instead, try, “How can we improve efficiency in a way that supports everyone’s concerns?”
• Drama Triangle Roles – The Conscious Leadership Group describes the Drama Triangle as a cycle that keeps leaders stuck in reactive patterns. Leaders can unknowingly take on Victim, Villain, or Hero roles. For example:
  • Villain: “My team keeps resisting change.” (Blame)
  • Hero: “I have to fix everything.” (Over-functioning)
  • Victim: “Leadership decisions are unfair to me.” (Helplessness)
• Forced Communication – Name-calling, controlling, or shutting down ideas stops collaboration before it starts. Instead of demanding agreement, invite diverse perspectives.

Recognizing these roles allows leaders to engage with responsibility rather than reaction.

---

Leadership Strategies for Productive Conflict

Effective leaders approach conflict as an opportunity for growth rather than a problem to avoid. One key strategy is fostering psychological safety, ensuring that team members feel secure expressing differing viewpoints without fear of retaliation. Another is embracing curiosity over control, where leaders ask open-ended questions and seek to understand rather than push for immediate resolution. Regulating emotional responses also plays a crucial role—leaders set the tone by managing their own reactions, creating an environment where discussions remain constructive. Lastly, building mutual purpose ensures that disagreements focus on shared goals rather than personal agendas, keeping conversations solution-oriented and collaborative.

I always like the following techniques as well:

• Embrace the “And” – Instead of framing choices as either/or, leaders should ask: How can we balance competing needs? For example:
  • Instead of: “Should we prioritize growth or employee well-being?”
  • Try: “How can we grow the company while supporting our team?”

• Use the CRIB Framework in Tough Leadership Conversations as outlined in Crucial Conversations, helps leaders restore safety in discussions:
  • C – Commit to finding mutual purpose.
  • R – Recognize the deeper needs behind each perspective.
  • I – Invent new options that honor both sides.
  • B – Brainstorm solutions that align with shared goals.

• Acknowledge & Validate all day long —Without Agreeing – Saying “I see why that’s frustrating,” keeps discussions open, while saying “That’s not true,” can escalate tension.

---

Leadership Call to Action

Think about a leadership challenge where conflict has emerged.
Consider:

1. What assumptions might be blocking resolution?
2. How could reframing invite better dialogue?
3. What communication shifts would create more psychological safety?
4. How can you lead disagreement with curiosity instead of control?

Leaders who embrace constructive disagreement strengthen teams, build trust, and inspire innovation. Are you ready to shift your approach? Let’s continue the conversation.

---

---

Erin Taylor Coaching Offerings

As a certified leadership coach, I empower teams to unlock their full potential with the DiSC assessment and The Five Behaviors of a Team.

Whether you’re looking to enhance leadership effectiveness or build a more cohesive team, these tools provide the insights and strategies needed for lasting success. Let’s elevate your team’s performance together! View my offerings now.

---